Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Does a child with special needs need treatment under General Anesthesia?

The dental treatment of a child with special needs is a challenge because very often the child cannot cooperate. Is the pediatric dentist right in posting such children under general anesthesia, or are there alternatives to be explored before we rush to fill in that hospital admission slip. DCSN asked some leading practioners of Pediatric Dentistry to give us their opinion on the issue. Each of them is given a rating corresponding to their inclination towards 
Chairside management under LA 
or
Management Under GA or Nitrous Oxide 

Prof Dr Usha Mohan Das 

 

 

Prof Dr PB Sood                       

Dr Anil Kumar Reddy    

   

 

Prof Dr Amitha Hegde                 

Prof Dr MS Muthu 

 

 

Prof Dr AR Prabhakar        

Prof Dr Ponnudurai A  


 

Dr Ashwin Jawdekar

  



Prof Dr Sashikiran

 

 

 

Our Take
As a site that has been stressing the improtance of prevention, we ideally believe that we should prevent the child from ever requiring operative treatment. However, blissful as this scenario may seem, it is highly unlikely. After taking into consideration the opinions of our experts the editorial team of DCSN recommends that every child must be given a chance to cooperate. We would be failing as pedodontists if we did not attempt to manage the child on the dental chair. We understand that this may not always work, and that invariably a few children will have to be posted under General Anesthesia, but we do not subscribe to the philosophy that a possible failure to manage the child on the chairside is reason enough to defer treatment to the operating theater.
Our Advice to parents is that, you must give your child every right to co-operate on the Dentist's chair before you agree to let the child be placed under general anesthesia.
Dr Sharat Chandra Pani
Editor
DCSN

Dr Usha Mohandas

Prof Dr Usha Mohandas; President of the Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry  is Principal of the VS Dental College Bangalore. She is not only a practitioner of Pediatric Dentistry in Bangalore but is also actively involved in reaching out to Children with special needs through her "gift a smile foundation"
 I believe that a person who recommends GA  for any child should be shot!!!.... Unless it is ABSOLUTELY indicated. There are very clear guidelines on this and I feel we should tread very carefully in this field. I think the challenge of being a pediatric dentist is the struggle, the skill involved in managing a child in the dental chair. I feel I have failed as a pedodontist if I resort to General Anesthesia because I feel it is “Easy” or worse, because it is “lucrative”. A lot many people would like to work on children when they are sleeping, it is cowardice and because of the money involved I would even go so far as describe it as abuse. I am a traditional Pedodontist who believes in doing every case under LA unless it is absolutely contraindicated. I will resort to GA only as a last resort and the guidelines for those guidelines are evident to every ethical dentist, and they will use GA as a necessary tool; not the next successful pedodontic business strategy

Dr. Ashwin Jawdekar

Dr Ashwin Jawdekar is an Alumnus of Nair Hospital Dental College Mumbai. An exclusive practitioner of Pediatric Dentistry in Thane, he is also an Associate  Professor of Pedodontics at MGM Dental College, Navi Mumbai.
Even children with special care needs should be given a fair chance to cooperate and dentists must explore all possibilities of achieving cooperation (including minimal physical restraints) prior to considering GA. It does, however, depend on a lot of factors such as the type and extent of disability, amount  and nature of treatment to be performed, whether the treatment need is urgent (emergency) or planned, fitness of the child for GA and parent's expectations and concerns.  I have managed to carry out multiple extractions and restorations for a Down Syndrome child using 'modified' behaviour modificationand a few RMGIC restorations for an autistic child on parent's lap wrapped in a bedsheet, assisted with mouthprop and 6 handed dentistry.

Prof Ponnudurai

Dr Ponnudurai Arangannal is Professor and Head of the Department at Sri Ramachandra Dental College Chennai. 

 We try to manage children with special needs on the chairside, and in the 15 years I have been practicing it has been my experience that they invariably land up in the operation theatre. Depending on the severity of the disability and the extent of treatment I decide whether the child needs to be managed in the clinic or the OT. Managing a Special Child in the clinic can be embarrassing, even if we decide to treat the child in the clinic; my advice would be to call the child at a time when other patients are not present. It is an uncomfortable experience, I’m sure if you go to a hospital and are faced with someone who is really sick, then even you would not be very comfortable. And most textbooks give clear guidelines as to the treatment of these children under general anesthesia, so I feel it is better for everyone concerned, the dentist, the parent and the patient to treat these children in the OT.

Dr Anil K Reddy

Dr Anil Reddy is a Board Certified Pediatric Dentist practicing in the United States. He has specialized in special care dentistry, both from the UK and the US. 

I am a strong believer in the use of nitrous oxide in all my special needs patients. This is probably because i am almost always referred patients whom other dentists cannot manage. Conscious sedation does not work because if you give him oral medicine wothout nitrous oxide you will probably only agitate him further. The purpose of oral sedation is to get the kid to put the mask on, the actual sedation requires nitrous oxide.Just medicine brings about a paradoxical reaction, they tend to fight it and because of suppression of the limbic system it makes the person more agitated. I really hope the Indian Dental council and Medical council will take steps to make it possible for dentists to monitor Nitorus Oxide sedation without the presence of the anesthesiologist

Prof MS Muthu

Prof MS Muthu is an exclusive pediatric dental practitioner in Chennai with a keen interest in special needs dentistry. He is also Professor of Pedodontics at Meenakshi Ammal Dental College Chennai

First of all we must try under local anesthesia or physical restraints; this is greatly influenced by the quantum of care required. For a single extraction or a restoration we can always do it under local anesthesia, but if it is a question of full mouth rehabilitation then may probably have to post the patient under general anesthesia. As a pediatric dentist working with special needs children for the past 12 years I can say with confidence that I have only used it only when it has become necessary. An attempt was always made on the dental chair, even if the patient was three years or two and a half years old we always tried first on the dental chair. You never know which patient will co-operate; there have been instances when children have cooperated irrespective of their age or underlying condition. I believe that as a pediatric dentist you can assess what the child’s behaviour is going to be like and then it is our duty to inform the parent that if we continue with attempts under Local Anesthesia then the quality of work will suffer.

Prof Dr PB Sood

Professor PB Sood is one of the most senior Pedodontists in India, an alumnus of PGI Chandigarh he has headed many prestigious pedodontics departments in India and is veiwed as a guide an mentor by many senior pedodontists in India.

You see I come from a school of thought at PGI Chandigarh where we always prefer to use behaviour management techniques. Behaviour management is the backbone of pediatric dentistry. I do not say that general anesthesia is contraindicated, you have definite indications and uses for it, but you have to first try behaviour management. The trend nowadays is that if you have a child who is making a little noise or fuss you slap him with sedation or general anesthesia. I do not aggree that this is either appropriate or ethical.

Prof. Dr Sashikiran

Prof Sashikiran is a Professor at Bapuji Dental College and Hospital

For a very uncooperative child or a child who cannot cooperate, general anesthesia is the only solution. Instead of going for sedation or chairside management I would definitely recommend Taking the child directly under GA. The problem with trying first under LA and failing is that the child becomes extremely uncooperative. Therefore I feel that taking up extremely uncooperative children under GA is the best solution.

Prof Dr AR Prabhakar

Professor Prabhakar is Head of the Department of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry, Bapuji Dental College Davengere. 

I am a very conservative man and I would definitely say Local anesthesia first. If it fails then we can use general anesthesia, but I do not discourage the use of LA.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

Special Care Dentistry: A Global Perspective

Dr Anil Reddy is a Board Certified Pediatric Dentist practicing in the United States. He has specialized in special care dentistry, both from the UK and the US. An alumnus of GDC Hyderabad he visits India regularly and has been a keen observer of the dental scenario here. He spoke exclusively to DCSN on the role of Pediatric Dentists in special care dentistry, and the status of the specialization in India. In the interview he also tells us about how funds can be raised for the treatment of these children and the role of sedation in the management of these children.

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Special Needs Dentistry is Nowhere in India: Dr. Usha Mohandas


Prof Dr Usha Mohandas; President of the Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry  is Principal of the VS Dental College Bangalore. Over her last two years as president she has gained the reputation of one who does not to mince her words. In this hard hitting interview with DCSN she tells us where she sees special needs dentistry in India - past present and future.


Dr Usha Mohandas: Before you begin let me say I will be absolutely honest….

DCSN: Where do you see special needs dentistry  India?

Dr UM: Nowhere!

DCSN: What do you feel can be done to correct that perception?

Dr UM: Firstly you need to have integrity among the fraternity, second; you need a common consensus on where we need to be on this issue and only then can you move forward on this issue.

DCSN: We are supposed to be pedodontists and preventive dentiststs, what preventive care do you feel we can provide children with special needs?

Dr UM : I feel as ISPPD president, the ISPPD should first know what ISPPD stands for. I feel all of us; and I don’t just mean committee members, but every pedodontist should come together, either in the for of a symposium or some other common forum to reach out to children with special needs. They are the ones who need us the most; not children who can be managed by any dentist. I feel that many dentists have no idea as to how many handicapped children are there in this country or what our obligations to them are. When you say dentistry for the “handicapped” I feel it is the dentist who is handicapped. This will require a spirit of cameraderie and will also require someone who to be  extremely committed an extremely human.

DCSN: Websites like these are reaching out to an extremely small audience; what in your opinion can be done to reach out to large sections of our population?

Dr UM: It is true that a very  very small percentage of our population is cyber savvy, but it is a very good beginning for those of you who are young and are interested in using the internet for a positive purpose. My objection is however that the internet is turning from .com to a dot con. There are people who simply “borrow” ideas from here and there making it impossible for people to get credible information.  Also there is a tendency to overstate western models. A Western experience can only serve as a base for creating something simplistic yet highly effective.This has to be done by holding several central forae so as to alllow us to create a strong central structure. Only  s believe you need a strong central sturcture only when this is done can we move on and truly disseminate this inforamtion to every region of the country, be it north, south east or west. This will take time and until then I believe we must work as best as we can for only when this is done can we move on to a larger base.

DCSN: Very often Pediatric Dentists are perplexed by the LA vs GA question. Should we try to treat children with Special Needs in the dental chair or as one senior professor told us, do you feel it is “Impractical”?

Dr UM: I believe that a person who recommends GA  for any child should be shot!!!.... Unless it is ABSOLUTELY indicated. There are very clear guidelines on this and I feel we should tread very carefully in this field. I think the challenge of being a pediatric dentist is the struggle, the skill involved in managing a child in the dental chair. I feel I have failed as a pedodontist if I resort to General Anesthesia because I feel it is “Easy” or worse, because it is “lucrative”. A lot many people would like to work on children when they are sleeping, it is cowardice and because of the money involved I would even go so far as describe it as abuse. I am a traditional Pedodontist who believes in doing every case under LA unless it is absolutely contraindicated. I will resort to GA only as a last resort and the guidelines for those guidelines are evident to every ethical dentist, and they will use GA as a necessary tool; not the next successful pedodontic business strategy.

DCSN: We get a lot of mail from parents of children with special needs asking about a diet to prevent decay. Where do you think we can step in and if there is some programme that you would like to be your legacy what would that programme be?

Dr UM: Firstly my priority would not be children who are worried about a diet, but children worried about food; getting one square meal a day. That said, there is a need to bridge the vast gap that exists between the haves and the have nots in our country. I truly believe that in order to reach dental care to all children with special healthcare needs requires a burning desire to serve and not just make money. I truly believe we can tap into the resources available, so many people donate to the cause of medical needs for special children, we can set up charitable trusts that reach dental care to every child with special needs not just the privileged few. I personally have setup a foundation called gift a smile, you can contact us at www.giftasmilefoundation.org . This forum reaches out not only to service providers but also to parents, who play the most important role in the carrying out of home care instructions.

DCSN: In a world where there are so many privileges in the hands of so few, what are your views on fund raising in India? Do you feel that that we have a long way to go in the evolution of a viable dental insurance programme?

Dr UM : Firstly let me say that I do not feel that funds raised always reach the people they were intended for. The important thing is that we have to start somewhere. I personally have been able to reach out through the corporate sector to over 75000 children in the span of one year, This has been done through the bare minimum collection from each individual. Furthermore, we have also been able to start a Dental Insurance of sorts among the rural children of Bangalore. A programme that collects just Rs.20 from every child at the beginning of the year and then provides dental  health care all year round. This programme was inaugurated by His Excellency Dr APJ Abdul Kalam himself. We are doing wonders through various programmes such as mid-day meals and so on. It’s really easy if you keep it simple. If you start simple it is easy to go big, I feel that you need simple management techniques, along with able executors which I feel is seriously lacking in our Indian Pediatric Dental fraternity. I think our committees should be able committees with the burning desire to succeed, and not just political committees that pull the society in whichever direction is suitable.

DCSN: Finally what would be your advice to any young Pediatric Dentist who would want to persue this field?

Dr UM: The youth are the key to the success of any programme, they have the energy and the “Brawn Power”. The young also have newer and more innovative ideas and can take the profession to great heights, provided they fall back on the experience of the old.

Don’t think twice about special child dentistry!

Professor MS Mutthu graduated in Pedodontics from the Nair memorial dental college 12 years ago and was one of the first exclusive practitioners in pediatric dentistry in Chennai. He has a keen interest in special needs dentistry and his exclusive pediatric dental practice Pedo Planet in Chennai is a special experience for all children. He shared his experiences on his long and often lonely foray into the field of Special Care Dentistry

DCSN: Where do you see special care dentistry in India?

Dr MSM: I think it has a long way to go, because the training in Special Care Dentistry in India is very very limited in a rather well established Pediatric Dental training programme.

DCSN: Do you feel that dentistry for Special needs children is an instinct or is it something that can be developed over time?

Dr MSM: You definitely need an aptitude but there is so much that can be done to improve the field, and make it more attractive to a young post-graduate. In the last few years I’ve made a couple of trips to developed countries and I find that their whole approach to special needs dentistry is different. They have separate buildings or wards, the students are trained separately in the treatment of such individuals. We will have to change our Pediatric Dentistry programme to include perhaps one module or exam in special needs dentistry, only then can we move forward.

DCSN: When you started out you were one of the few people practicing special needs dentistry; over the years have you seen things change or do you feel that things are just as bad as they were?

Dr MSM: No things have definitely changed over the years. When I started out people were not even aware of the concept of a pediatric dentist, or that we had better training to deal with children with special needs. Now with the greater number Pediatric dentists coming out awareness is slowly. Having said that I have to point out that the creation of awareness is our job. We as pediatric dentists have to go out and tell parents of children with special needs about the work we do, and why we can provide better care for these children. We cannot sit back and cry about the lack of awareness.

DCSN: In the west the field is Special Care dentistry and not just restricted to special children but also adults with systemic disorders or disability. In India who do you see filling that gap?

Dr MSM:Well as you pointed out Special care in the West refers to not just children but also medically compromised patients, but I don’t feel that as Pediatric dentists we should feel restricted, we can provide care to medically compromised patients of all ages: IF we have the necessary training.

DCSN: Would you prefer to treat a child with special needs under LA or Ga?

Dr MSM: First of all we must try under local anesthesia or physical restraints; this is greatly influenced by the quantum of care required. For a single extraction or a restoration we can always do it under local anesthesia, but if it is a question of full mouth rehabilitation then we may probably have to post the patient under general anesthesia. As a pediatric dentist working with special needs children for the past 12 years I can say with confidence that I have only used it only when it has become necessary. An attempt was always made on the dental chair, even if the patient was three years or two and a half years old we always tried first on the dental chair. You never know which patient will co-operate; there have been instances when children have cooperated irrespective of their age or underlying condition. I believe that as a pediatric dentist you can assess what the child’s behaviour is going to be like and then it is our duty to inform the parent that if we continue with attempts under Local Anesthesia then the quality of work will suffer.

DCSN: Any Advice to parents?

Dr MSM: Take care of your child’s teeth. I can understand that with all the underlying conditions you have probably been rushing in and out of hospitals for the greater part of your child’s life and those teeth have a low priority. But do consult a pediatric dentist as early as possible so as to prevent dental disease in the child. I also believe that only a pediatric dentist has the training and the skill required to provide dental care to a special child.

DCSN: Where do you see the future of special care Dentistry in India?

Dr MSM: I definitely see a great improvement in this area, as the field expands the number of people who are going to want to specialize into an area of special interest such as this will also increase. Furthermore as we have seen in the west, I can see specialty programmes for the care of individuals with special health needs in India as well.

DCSN: If any young dentist came up to you and said he wanted to specialize in special care dentistry what would your advice to him/her be?

Dr MSM: Don’t think twice. Go ahead and do it, because when you will look back at your career 10 years from now you will be glad you made the choice.

Monday, November 17, 2008

Special Care Dentistry:Home and Abroad

Dr Anil Reddy is a Board Certified Pediatric Dentist practicing in the United States. He has specialized in special care dentistry, both from the UK and the US. An alumnus of GDC Hyderabad he visits India regularly and has been a keen observer of the dental scenario here. He spoke exclusively to DCSN on the role of Pediatric Dentists in special care dentistry, and the status of the specialization in India. In the interview he also tells us about how funds can be raised for the treatment of these children and the role of sedation in the management of these children.

DCSN: Why special needs dentistry?

Dr Anil Reddy:For me personally I felt after my training as a pediatric dentistry that here was a field where I could do something. During my residency I came across children with hearing impairment, visual impairment, and autism and I realized we were the only people with the know how and the patience to help these children. The general dentists would not treat them and parents kept bringing them back to us, so I did one more year of special needs training under the united cerebral palsy founadation. Now in an ideal world I would wish there was not a single special needs patient, but that’s not how the real world works, there are going to be individuals with certain disabilites who have certain dental needs and we need to help them. There can be no if’s and buts about that. We take a hippocratic oath to serve all  patients, and if nobody helps them then there’s something seriously wrong with society we live in.

 

DCSN: Where do you think special needs dentistry in India is today, and where do you think it can be tomorrow?

Dr AR:When you think of special needs dentistry, you have to think of it as someting where you are going to be helping these individuals. With interested groups such as your site and some of the dental schools I see the scenario slowly changing.

DCSN: Special needs special costs. Do you agree?

Dr AR:Yes. You see I am a big believer in the merits of capitalism, alturism has it’s limits, there is only so much you can do through charity. Ultimately the money has to come from somewhere. As a practitioner, if I go to the suppliers of dental materials or chairs they will not give you the materials free simply because you tell them your motives are pure. So it is a valid cost. But if you can get funding from somewhere, then you don’t have to pass on the full burden of those costs to the parent.

DCSN: Now in the United States you have a well established healthcare payment system. Who do you see bearing those costs in a country such as India where third party payment is still in it’s infancy?

Dr AR:You would have to reach out to the relegious institutions. In the US or the UK relegious groups play a very important role in providing health care. I graduated from Columbia University, but our clinic was funded by the Presbyterian Church. Similarly you had Long Island Jewish, Baylor college in Texas is funded by the Baptist Church… all major schools are supported by these relegious groups. So in a country like India where you have such strong traditional relegious values, schools would have to reach out to them to fund Special Needs Dentistry. The government can also step in and help.

DCSN: Of all the special needs conditions, which of them is the most challenging?

Dr AR:Clinically I would have to day that Cerebral Palsy is the most challenging, simply because the child has very little under his/her own control. But if you take special needs as a whole each case is a challenge unto itself, each patient presents a unique problem to you, and there in lies the beauty of special needs dentistry. I feel you should take each patient as an opportunity from god to serve humanity. You may not be able to give the best of treatment, there have been times when I’ve done scaling for a cerebral palsy patient and I’ve had to leave the occlusal calculus as a sealant, simply because the child could not cooperate, I had to concentrate on the gingival areas. You may not do an ideal job but you’ve got to do the best you can. If in your heart you feel you have helped the patient then that is the best reward for the challenge.

DCSN: Special needs dentists have to deal with the pain of having a terminally ill patient or losing a patient . Does special needs dentistry take a toll on you emotionally? Do you need to have a heart of steel so as to not get hurt?

Dr AR:It does, to a certain level yes, you are not human if it doesn’t effect you emotionally. But it’s like in Pediatric Dentistry, the first time a kid cries, you are affected, but over a period of time  you learn to manage your emotions better. I wouldn’t agree with the term steel heart, because that would be like saying we are heartless, which is false. It will wear you down but if in your heart you have the faith that you are doing the right thing, then that’s where your energy comes from.

DCSN: You are coming form the United States, where there has been a raging debate about the right to life. As a special needs dentist who is faced with this situation more often than others, where do you stand?

Dr AR:My answer is that the right to choose that lies only with the parents. I understand that conditions such as severe cerebral palsy or Down syndrome can take a toll on the parents. But if the parents are aware of the efforts involved, and are willing to put in the extra efforts then we have no right to take a life away.

DCSN: We can learn special needs dentistry, but what can we learn from special needs dentistry?

Dr AR:From these kids we learn to be human beings. They go through so much in life, be it medical procedures or surgeries, and yet when they step into your office they are smiling. That I think teaches us a lot about life.

Monday, November 10, 2008

30th ISPPD Conference Hyderabad

The Indian Society of Pedodontics and Preventive Dentistry is conducting it's 30th annual national conference at Hyderabad from the 13th - 15th November 2008. The society is a forum for pediatric dentists across India to share their ideas. Dentistry for children with special needs will bring you the abstracts of all papers related to special needs dentistry. So watch this space to find out what's new in the field of special care dentistry in India.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Keep that drill at bay- A cream to reverse dental caries



The dentist's drill is perhaps one of the scariest parts of a dental visit. Add to this the aversion to noise of an autistic child or the startle reflex of a child with cerebral palsy and you get a situation that is unpleasant for dentist, child and parent alike. A high speed drill also requires the child to stay still during the procedure to prevent the dentist from accidentally nicking the tongue or cheek. All in all the drilling of a cavity is a task that is best kept at bay.Prevention is better than cure, but traditionally dentists  have viewed prevention as the steps taken to prevent dental decay such as brushing, flossing and in some cases even topical fluorides. Once dental decay sets in, however,the age old adage of "Drill-Fill-Bill" is the chosen response of the dentist. But things are changing - for the better.
CPP-ACP the remineralization cream
Casein-Phospho-Peptide Amorphous-Calcium-Phosphate; or CPP-ACP for short is a topically applied agent that helps restore calcium lost due to bacterial acids back into your child's teeth.The role of calcium in the prevention of dental disease is perhaps the most misrepresented of all dental facts. Toothpaste ads constantly show a dentist (or someone pretending to be one) telling you how calcium will make your child's tooth "strong" and prevent caries, when the actual role of calcium in toothpastes is to act as an abrasive that cleans your tooth! 
How Does it Work?
In the 1990's researchers began to notice that certain types of cheese, such as cheddar, actually helped to reduce caries. Further research showed that Casein - the milk protein that cheese is rich in binds to dental plaque - the film of deposits on your teeth and helps restore calcium that has been depleted due to acids produced by bacteria. The calcium in the teeth is in the form of calcium phosphate. A team of Australian dentists led by Prof EC Reynolds at the University of Melbourne found that a creme combining Casein with amorphous calcium phosphate not only attached to the tooth but also provided the calcium ions for the tooth. Thus CPP-ACP was born and the first commercial paste Recaldent was launched.



The Casein forms a layer on the surface of the tooth while the Calcium and phosphate ions of the creme enter the tooth. The complex also attracts more calcium and phosphate ions from the saliva




How to use it

Ever since the early success of recaldent, CPP-ACP has found itself in chewing gums, creams and toothpastes. In India currently only the cream is marketed. The cream can either be loaded onto a tray supplied by the manufacturer and applied to all the teeth or a small amount can be taken on a clean finger and applied to the affected tooth. Since the best action of the cream is when it is placed for prolonged periods of time the best time to apply it would be after the night time brush. 

Contraindications

Since the cream is made up of milk protein it is contraindicated in people who have hereditary protein intolerance. The cream does not contain fluoride and if you are worried about fluoride ingestion, especially by children with CP who cannot control their swallow, then CPP-ACP provides a safe alternative.

Listed below are a series of links featuring products that contain CPP-ACP and the countries in which they are available.

Recaldent Gums (Japan)

http://www.breezecare.co.uk/ukcard/recaldent.html

Trident Xtra Care Gums (US)
http://www.tridentgum.com/#/products/xtracare/coolmint

GC Tooth Mousse (Asia, Europe, through dentists)
http://www.gceurope.com/en/products/detail.php

GC MI Paste & GC MI Paste Plus
http://www.mi-paste.com/
http://www.gcamerica.com/

Liked this post and would like more scientific research on CPP-ACP? click here